Healing The Healthy - A Very Ethical Problem

Healthy.png

We are living in times in which many ailments which used to disable or even kill, have been brought under control with medical drugs and procedures. For instance in Victorian England, one of the most common killers came via infection caught from a rotten tooth.

That's right, before the dawn of antibiotics toothache, along with a whole host of other minor infections, was a major danger to your life.

Today we have a plethora of drugs that make things like tetanus, gangrene, and abscesses, minor inconveniences, rather than life threatening traumas.

However these benefits are not for all, for instance, if you are unfortunate enough to contract HIV, then your survival chances depend very much on your geographical location.

A Perfect Imbalance

If for instance you contract HIV in the UK, you are likely to live around 5-10 years less than you would have done had you not caught the disease.

So if your lifestyle choices and genetics meant that without accident, you would live to 80 years of age, then with proper treatment you can have HIV and live to about 70 or 75.

Of course you will have to take a cocktail of up to eighteen different pills everyday, and those pills will play havoc on your liver and bones. However you will be alive and have the chance to enjoy your life.

This is not the case if you live in say Nigeria, Nepal, or India. Unless you are wealthy enough to travel to a wealthier country, or import the drugs you need, you are looking at 1-5 years before you die.

This is the sad truth of the world we live in, miracle cures are often for sale at a price only some can afford.

A Cure For The Healthy

We are so lucky in the developed world, that now we are approaching a time whereby the healthy will be undergoing medical procedures. Not to cure them of any ailments, but rather to enhance an already privileged existence.

The dawn of transhumanism is upon us, the next two or so decades will see possibly millions of human beings augmenting their biology and possibly altering their DNA, all in the name of enhancement.

With the advent of quantum computing around the corner, it won't be long before we will be able to edit out risk of disease in our children's DNA, or enhance our ability to learn language, see in the dark, or even increase our general intelligence.

The possibilities for enhancements and augmentations will grow and grow. This growth will lead to a brand new ethical dilemma.

I'm Alright Jack

Of course it is easy for me to sit here and muse about a possible future whereby people I have never met are frozen out of a system that benefits me. However when it comes down to it, I, and nobody else who has the willing and the capital will turn down life-extending enhancements because of these ethical quagmires.

That doesn't mean that I embrace the inequality, or indeed am not sickened by it. It is just that human nature will mean that I want to protect the lives of me and my family, more than those of people I don't know.

So the ideal scenario is whereby I can enjoy the fruits of the medical profession's labour, guilt free; however I have to wonder if this will ever be possible.

Social Darwinism At Its Worst

Imagine a world whereby only the wealthy survive beyond a certain point, and their children are healthier than their poorer counterparts.

After a while, only they and their children would be left. Darwin showed us how in nature, only the fittest and most adaptable survive in a changing environment.

Perhaps now we are moving into the epoch of survival of the richest.

DO YOU SEE ANY ETHICAL DILEMMAS WHEN IT COMES TO BODY ENHANCEMENT AND AUGMENTATION? SHOULD THIS TECHNOLOGY BE FOR EVERYONE; OR SHOULD WE ACCEPT THAT IT MAY BE THE FEW WHO HAVE ACCESS? AS EVER, LET ME KNOW BELOW!

Cryptogee

Sort:  

It's true times are changing!

Faster than we can imagine!

Cg

This subject is highly debatable and it caught my eye because I was employed in pharmaceutics not so long ago. I think that health care (and by that I mean advanced health care of more developed countries) should be given to everyone that needs them. I debated some people about the subject, and this maybe sounds utopian to you, but I vision a self-sustainable pharmaceutical and health industry. I know it is difficult to do this now, but in the future we could probably do it, and as I always say (it became almost like a mantra to me): people lack empathy! Have a nice day.

It is an interesting topic, and one that will grab more and more headlines in the next decade or so. I think your vision might one day be possible via blockchain economics. Here's hoping :-)

Cg

I thought of it too. I even written about it regarding the music industry. But time will show if we were right. One way or the other, this current situation is not sustainable.

Yes you raise the right point ONLY THE WEALTHY SURVIVES!...... going to reblog this..people need to know this.

Times are changing indeed! Your reference to Nigeria as regards HIV contraction is patently true as there are no mechanisms on ground to help them. Nigeria is in a rotten state and only God will help.
There is nothing as good as healthy living. It begets wonderful lifestyle and serene frame of mind.

Yes it is a sad state of affairs, I don't think God can help, if he could, he would have done already... It will take the will of honest politicians and the people to change things. Perhaps the blockchain will prove to be a democratic solution.

Cg

Times are changing at a rapid rate due to technology.

Having studied the subject for a while, I think there are certain ethical dilemmas concerning body enhancements, and it can't be for everyone.

we can debate until the end of time but then if we do that then chances are we become the people who won't make it through, unfortunately progress comes at the expensive often of the thinkers and the pre woke! :) - i accept our robot overlords.

I not only accept them, I will become them! :-)

Cg

The quality of life every time empora in the countries of development pathways because more and more nurses are created and the pharmaceutical companies become richer, so it is urgently needed to change this system where all people have access to live dignified Mind is to say happy as long as there is life

I mean if we think about it deeply, we are already there... Not in the technology, but in terms of how we live now. And let me assure you I am as guilty as anyone! For example, when we are thirsty we can go to the tap and get some nice water to drink. Yet that isn't enough, we usually (at least here in the US) buy even "better" bottled water at the store.... all the while 5000 children die every day for lack of clean water...yet we barely bat an eye--myself included!!! I do not have any answers mind you, I am just pointing the finger at myself and asking why.
I really enjoyed thinking from your post.

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2006/nov/10/water.environment

Yes that particular statistic is just awful, this is why I hate to hear sports stars 'thank god' for helping them win a meaningless sporting event, it's like sure; he helped you win a football game instead of saving a dying child...

In particular the medical divide is getting bigger and bigger, the fact is, it is still possible to contract leprosy in India! This is simply due to the fact that they do not have freely available antibiotics. Again, when I hear people in the west complaining about 'Big Pharma' it really makes me sick. I think to myself; 'yeah, go and live in Delhi for a year and then tell me you don't want to be vaccinated or have any evil antibiotics in you!'

However I think this is different, as I alluded to above, we are moving to a place whereby we will have the enhanced and the unenhanced, and the enhanced will outlive their poorer counterparts...

Cg

YES! Exactly right!

Yes I agree and see the difference. Sorry to have ranted or sidetracked. Its just a thing I am passionate about and disturbed about. I dont have the answer, yet again maybe we do. Maybe part of the answer is to be found in cryptos? I dont know...

I have the sense that other problems will arise if we begin editing DNA for the risk of diseases. The problem is that the human mind isn't as intelligent as the nature we are made of and we often think we are making brilliant changes but they often bring along different kinds of problems.

Yes sometimes we may not think about the future enough, however I think it's generally positive, I would have love to have been able to screen our DNA and edit out any potential life threatening, congenital ailments our daughter might contract in the future.

The problem at the moment is it takes an extremely long time to mimic and indeed work out how proteins fold, which is the key to working out DNA. I think once quantum computing kicks in, those problems will disappear.

I hear ya though about playing god :-)

Cg